Political Ideology Atlas · All ideologies · Take the test
Third camp
The third camp is the socialist position, born in the Second World War, of opposing both the capitalist-imperialist bloc and the Stalinist bloc and organising an independent working-class camp against both. It holds that the Soviet-type states are exploitative class societies, not socialism, and that socialism must come from below through the self-emancipation of workers and the freedom of colonial peoples, with democracy as its condition.
What it stands for
- History is mainly driven by conflict between economic classes.
- Western political institutions are suitable for every civilization.
- Wars between great powers are an unavoidable consequence of capitalism.
- Owners' profit is value taken from workers' labor.
- Cooperation between employers and workers should not come before conflict where their interests differ.
- Workers should form a party of their own, separate from the parties already in place.
Key figures
- Max Shachtman: Leader of the Workers Party who developed bureaucratic collectivism and the Third Camp slogan.
- Hal Draper: Main theorist of 'socialism from below' within the tradition.
Closest ideologies
- Shachtmanism (94% match)
- Marxist humanism (92% match)
- Socialist democracy (92% match)
- Western Marxism (91% match)
- De Leonism (91% match)
People closest to it
- Rosa Luxemburg (92% alike)
- Eugene V. Debs (91% alike)
- William Morris (88% alike)
- John Dewey (87% alike)
- Hasan Piker (87% alike)
Key positions
- Strongly: History is mainly driven by conflict between economic classes.
- Strongly: Western political institutions are suitable for every civilization.
- Strongly: Wars between great powers are an unavoidable consequence of capitalism.
- Strongly: Owners' profit is value taken from workers' labor.
- Strongly: Cooperation between employers and workers should not come before conflict where their interests differ.
- Strongly: Workers should form a party of their own, separate from the parties already in place.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not tie a person's life to a sacred community that goes on after their death.
- Strongly: The nation does not need a radical rebirth to overcome decadence.
- Strongly: Working together internationally should count at least as much as my country's own priorities.
- Strongly: State schools should not teach religion.
- Strongly: Employees should have voting rights in the management of large companies.
- Strongly: Trade unions should control their own affairs without state direction.
- Strongly: Property need not be spread among many small owners.
- Strongly: Businesses should belong to the people who work in them, for example as cooperatives.
- Strongly: Allied countries are free to decide for themselves whether to help one that is attacked.
- Strongly: Having wealth does not by itself create a duty to help those who are worse off.
- Strongly: A country does not have the right to stop a region becoming independent by using its military.
- Strongly: High earners and the very rich should pay tax at a much higher rate than everyone else.
- Strongly: Production should be organised to provide what people need, instead of being organised around what yields a profit.
- Strongly: Children of citizens are not the only ones who should be citizens at birth.
- Strongly: My country may keep a military no stronger than its rivals'.
- Strongly: Without workers' own political power, state ownership is not socialism.
- Strongly: A country may accept its present border with a neighbour even if it lost land in an old war.
- Strongly: Real command of the military may rest with someone other than the head of state.
- Strongly: Non-citizens should also be eligible for welfare benefits.
- Strongly: The left-right division in politics remains meaningful.
- Strongly: Society may be changed in large, rapid steps.
- Strongly: Workers' solidarity with workers in other countries should count at least as much as solidarity with their own nation.
- Strongly: Ordinary legal protections, such as the right not to be held without trial, should stay in force even in a national emergency.
- Strongly: A country can get through deadlock among its institutions without a leader who overrides them.
- Strongly: You can't reach a free, fair society by unfree or unfair means.
- Strongly: Owners' rights to their property need not be protected against being overridden for public goals.
- Strongly: The law should impose no restrictions on strikes.
- Strongly: An electorate should choose the head of state, either directly or through elected representatives.
- Strongly: Government should rely at least as much on legal enforcement as on its rulers' moral example.
- Strongly: Officials decide what gets made and who gets it at least as well as prices and competition do.
- Strongly: Workers are better off for having labor unions.
- Strongly: Ethnic diversity does not weaken a society's ability to hold together.
- Strongly: The best constitution does not combine rule by the few with rule by the many.
- Strongly: People should have a direct role in making decisions where they work, live and study, rather than having those decisions made entirely for them.
- Strongly: A former empire should claim no special ties, leadership or sphere of influence in its old territories.
- Strongly: Politics is not best understood as a contest between spiritual good and evil.
- Strongly: Political representation should not come through social bodies such as families, local communities and occupational associations instead of political parties.
- Strongly: The general public should have at least as much say in policy as experts.
- Strongly: Private charity does not help people in poverty better than government programs do.
- Strongly: Nobody should hold a special rank by birth, such as a noble title, a hereditary crown or a caste position, or the special rights attached to one.
- Strongly: A nation does not need one main ethnic group: it can be made up of people of many ancestries.
- Strongly: Wages need not be set through negotiating bodies that the state officially recognizes.
- Strongly: Publicly honouring a national leader as the personification of the nation is not acceptable.
- Strongly: My country can do without nuclear weapons that it alone controls.
- Strongly: No one is better suited by nature to govern than anyone else.
- Strongly: The presence of people of its nationality does not give a state a rightful claim to land beyond its borders.
- Strongly: Restoring a lost social order does not matter more than pursuing progress.
- Strongly: Other things drive humanity forward at least as much as rivalry and conflict between peoples.
- Strongly: Art should not be censored for its effect on people's moral character.
- Strongly: Income-tax percentages may differ between income levels.
- Strongly: Racial groups should not each organise to defend distinct political interests of their own.
- Strongly: Very large concentrations of wealth threaten a free society.
- Strongly: My country should not send weapons to foreign insurgents, whatever it thinks of the governments they fight.
- Strongly: Leading roles in a country's economy should not depend on belonging to the majority national group.
- Strongly: War does not strengthen a nation's character.
- Strongly: Political violence is sometimes justified.
- Strongly: Income from useful work should be rewarded ahead of income from merely owning property.
- Strongly: Being powerful does not mean a country should bring more land within its borders.
- Strongly: The government should let its political opponents organise, speak and compete for power.
- Strongly: Rapid economic development does not justify temporary restrictions on political freedom.
- Strongly: Protecting the constitution should be left to civilian institutions, not the armed forces.
- Strongly: A national development strategy should not accept some regions growing wealthy ahead of the rest.
- Strongly: Political authority does not ultimately come from God.
- Strongly: Naturalized citizens may hold public office as well as people born in the country.
- Strongly: A socialist state with hostile neighbours need not build up its state power.
- Strongly: The leader should not bypass political intermediaries in dealing with the people.
- Strongly: A country may leave other nations to choose their own political systems.
- Strongly: A mother country and its colonies may trade with the outside world.
- Strongly: Businesses gain too much influence over government policy from their lobbying.
- Strongly: The law should treat everyone as an equal, whatever their birth, sex, race or status.
- Strongly: Being the first to use force can be right, depending on what it is meant to achieve.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not go with sharing its religion.
- Strongly: Someone who actually governs a state should not hand that power on to their own child.
- Strongly: An armed minority's actions are incapable of bringing about the conditions for a broader revolutionary uprising.
- Strongly: Laws should not be required to follow religious texts.
- Strongly: Looking after your own interests is not a moral good in itself.
- Strongly: At least some revolutions have been justified.
- Strongly: News media should decide for themselves what they publish, whoever holds power.
- Strongly: No party's ideology should give it an exclusive right to lead the state.
- Strongly: The law should not punish consenting adults for same-sex relations.
- Strongly: A state with a state-owned planned economy should not be defended against capitalist restoration under a ruling bureaucracy.
- Strongly: The armed forces may be controlled by someone other than the governing party's leadership.
- Strongly: Population growth does not mainly drive lasting poverty.
- Strongly: There is no deliberate plan behind immigration aimed at replacing the native population.
- Strongly: People of different races should not be discouraged from forming a family together, including through marriage and children.
- Strongly: No state may force a minority out of the country, however hostile it judges that minority to be.
- Strongly: Some areas of life should remain outside state direction.
- Strongly: Private owners' choice of whom they deal with should be subject to some restrictions.
- Strongly: No society has the right to rule another for its supposed improvement, however advanced it is.
- Strongly: The vote keeps a government in check at least as well as being able to leave the country does.
- Strongly: A market economy is incompatible with socialism under communist-party leadership.
- Strongly: The ruler should be subject to the country's laws.
- Strongly: Government should have other tasks besides protecting people from physical violence.
- Strongly: Collecting taxes does not in itself amount to stealing people's money.
- Strongly: Belonging to a religious minority is no ground for shoppers to stay away from a shop.
- Strongly: Great powers should have no right to send troops against allied governments' wishes for the purpose of preserving those countries' political systems.
- Strongly: Voting should not be limited to members of one ethnic group.
- Strongly: Overseas territories need not be run mainly for the ruling country's economic benefit.
- Strongly: Taking part in politics is at least as good a way to live as living privately away from public affairs.
- Strongly: People without property should also have the right to vote.
- Strongly: State schools need not steer pupils away from belief in God.
- Strongly: Public spaces such as schools and facilities should not be separated by race under the law.
- Strongly: Final authority over a state's laws need not belong to its most senior religious scholars.
- Leans: When rival great powers go to war, workers should work to make their own state lose.
- Leans: Keeping a nation's inherited culture alive, including its language, customs and traditions, is not important.
- Leans: Political power should rest on councils elected in workplaces in place of parliaments.
- Leans: Individual soldiers and conscripts have a duty to refuse to fight in state wars.
- Leans: Religion gives people a false consolation for hardship in their material lives.
- Leans: Political change should replace the existing administrative and coercive institutions with new forms of organization, rather than put new leaders in charge of the old apparatus.
- Leans: Society should aim for people to end up with broadly equal material conditions.
- Leans: Socialism in a single country will not endure without successful socialist revolutions in other countries.
- Leans: Historical change comes mainly from changes in how society produces and exchanges goods.
- Leans: Taking pride in one's racial group is not justified.
- Leans: Serving the nation does not mean serving its working people.
- Leans: A region should be entitled to leave its current country.
- Leans: Laws, police and government mainly serve the interests of whoever owns the economy and holds power.
- Leans: In the society we should aim for, a person's needs should determine their share of goods.
- Leans: Countries that had colonies should compensate the countries they colonized.
- Leans: Capitalist exchange makes people's economic relationships look like relationships among the goods they trade.
- Leans: Countries that feel dominated by Western powers may handle their relations with them separately.
- Leans: Wage work cuts people off from the meaning and creativity of what they make.
- Leans: Entertainment produced for mass audiences tends to weaken people's willingness to challenge the established social order.
- Leans: Women's subordination is tied to how the economy is organised, so reform of laws and attitudes is not enough.
- Leans: The ruling class stays in power mainly through people going along with its ideas.
- Leans: A general collapse of capitalism is unavoidable.
- Leans: Society should follow a third course beyond capitalism and communism.
- Leans: Elected officials have at least as much real power as the people who run the press, universities and other cultural institutions.
- Leans: Defeating communism should not take priority over coexistence with it.
- Leans: Government should serve people's good while respecting each person as more than an instrument of the state or community.
- Leans: My country should stay neutral and join neither of the opposing great-power alliances.
- Leans: Whether a policy fits an ideology should count independently of its results.
- Leans: Capitalism built the productive power and wealth that later and better societies rest on.
- Leans: The economy should not combine mainly private markets with government support for people who cannot meet their basic needs.
- Leans: Formal press freedom is hollow when wealth decides who can actually be heard.
- Leans: A head of state may take a side in party politics.
- Leans: Workers' pay should be settled in collective bargaining between their union and their employer.
- Leans: Political freedom can last without economic freedom.
- Leans: A person loses freedom from being at another person's mercy, even if that power is never exercised.
- Leans: People are entitled to resist a ruler's unconstitutional exercise of power.
- Leans: Killing another person can be right in self-defence or in defence of others.
- Leans: How someone turns out is shaped more by upbringing, society and experience than by the traits they are born with.
- Leans: Each country's communist party should decide its strategy for socialism without taking orders from another country's party.
- Leans: Direct action does not have to take the place of elections and parliament as the way to achieve political change.
- Leans: Recruitment to the civil service should not depend on competitive examinations.
- Leans: Countries should keep their armed forces.
- Leans: Society needs government of some kind.
- Leans: A workers' state does not need to suppress the old ruling class, even for a time.
- Leans: Political independence means little unless the economic and property system is also transformed.
- Leans: People may live and work outside communities that own their property together.
- Leans: Spreading democracy does not bring peace.
- Leans: Meeting poor people's needs should be the first consideration in public policy.
- Leans: Trade, finance and debt rules should be changed to give poorer countries a fairer share.
- Leans: Most people in political office look after themselves first and the public second.
- Leans: Private ownership is legitimate only insofar as it benefits society.
- Leans: Member states should keep the final decision on whether to follow UN decisions.
- Leans: Small, informal, trust-based groups should not take the place of lasting parties, unions and federations in political action.
- Leans: At most half of workers in wealthy countries benefit from the exploitation of poorer countries.
- Leans: A people with a shared national identity is entitled to its own self-governing state.
- Leans: Descendants of settlers need not be led politically by the country's original peoples.
- Leans: Workers do not need a disciplined revolutionary party to lead them.
- Leans: Poor countries should retain economic ties with rich countries.
- Leans: In an economy with common ownership of productive assets, people should still own their personal belongings.
- Leans: Groups have rights of their own.
- Leans: Individual farms should not give way to joint cultivation by groups of farmers.