Political Ideology Atlas · All ideologies · Take the test
Shachtmanism
Shachtmanism is the Marxist current built around Max Shachtman and the Workers Party that split from Trotskyism in 1940. It holds that the Soviet Union was neither capitalist nor a workers' state but a 'bureaucratic collectivist' society run by a new ruling class, and it adopts a Third Camp stance of backing neither Washington nor Moscow but the democratic struggles of workers and oppressed peoples. Its later social-democratic branch backed labor, civil rights and containment of Stalinism, while its left branch (Draper) stressed socialism from below.
What it stands for
- History is mainly driven by conflict between economic classes.
- Owners' profit is value taken from workers' labor.
- A nation's identity does not run in unbroken continuity from its ancient origins to the present.
- Cooperation between employers and workers should not come before conflict where their interests differ.
- Workers should form a party of their own, separate from the parties already in place.
- Individual rights matter at least as much as what citizens owe their community.
Key figures
- Max Shachtman: Founder of the Workers Party and chief theorist of bureaucratic collectivism and the Third Camp.
- Hal Draper: Foremost left Shachtmanite and author of 'The Two Souls of Socialism' (socialism from below).
Closest ideologies
- Third camp (94% match)
- Socialist democracy (92% match)
- Marxist humanism (91% match)
- Centrist Marxism (90% match)
- One-state solution (90% match)
People closest to it
- John Dewey (89% alike)
- Albert Einstein (89% alike)
- Eugene V. Debs (89% alike)
- Rosa Luxemburg (88% alike)
- Theodor W. Adorno (88% alike)
Key positions
- Strongly: History is mainly driven by conflict between economic classes.
- Strongly: Owners' profit is value taken from workers' labor.
- Strongly: A nation's identity does not run in unbroken continuity from its ancient origins to the present.
- Strongly: Cooperation between employers and workers should not come before conflict where their interests differ.
- Strongly: Workers should form a party of their own, separate from the parties already in place.
- Strongly: Individual rights matter at least as much as what citizens owe their community.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not tie a person's life to a sacred community that goes on after their death.
- Strongly: Working together internationally should count at least as much as my country's own priorities.
- Strongly: Living in a city does at least as much for a person's moral wellbeing as living in the countryside.
- Strongly: Trade unions should control their own affairs without state direction.
- Strongly: Foreign powers sometimes have a right to intervene in a country's internal affairs.
- Strongly: The Soviet economy was not capitalism under state ownership with the state in place of private capitalists.
- Strongly: Democracy is best even when voters make poor choices.
- Strongly: Without workers' own political power, state ownership is not socialism.
- Strongly: A country may accept its present border with a neighbour even if it lost land in an old war.
- Strongly: Real command of the military may rest with someone other than the head of state.
- Strongly: Workers' pay should be settled in collective bargaining between their union and their employer.
- Strongly: The left-right division in politics remains meaningful.
- Strongly: Workers' solidarity with workers in other countries should count at least as much as solidarity with their own nation.
- Strongly: Ordinary legal protections, such as the right not to be held without trial, should stay in force even in a national emergency.
- Strongly: A country can get through deadlock among its institutions without a leader who overrides them.
- Strongly: You can't reach a free, fair society by unfree or unfair means.
- Strongly: Owners' rights to their property need not be protected against being overridden for public goals.
- Strongly: The law should impose no restrictions on strikes.
- Strongly: An electorate should choose the head of state, either directly or through elected representatives.
- Strongly: Officials decide what gets made and who gets it at least as well as prices and competition do.
- Strongly: Workers are better off for having labor unions.
- Strongly: Ethnic diversity does not weaken a society's ability to hold together.
- Strongly: A former empire should claim no special ties, leadership or sphere of influence in its old territories.
- Strongly: Politics is not best understood as a contest between spiritual good and evil.
- Strongly: Political representation should not come through social bodies such as families, local communities and occupational associations instead of political parties.
- Strongly: The general public should have at least as much say in policy as experts.
- Strongly: Private charity does not help people in poverty better than government programs do.
- Strongly: Young people should not be organised into uniformed, drilled groups that prepare them to serve the nation.
- Strongly: Wages need not be set through negotiating bodies that the state officially recognizes.
- Strongly: Publicly honouring a national leader as the personification of the nation is not acceptable.
- Strongly: No one is better suited by nature to govern than anyone else.
- Strongly: The American Civil War arose mainly from slavery.
- Strongly: The presence of people of its nationality does not give a state a rightful claim to land beyond its borders.
- Strongly: Restoring a lost social order does not matter more than pursuing progress.
- Strongly: Other things drive humanity forward at least as much as rivalry and conflict between peoples.
- Strongly: Rulers have a right to rule only because the people they rule have agreed to it.
- Strongly: A national language may keep the foreign loanwords it has.
- Strongly: Art should not be censored for its effect on people's moral character.
- Strongly: Leading roles in a country's economy should not depend on belonging to the majority national group.
- Strongly: Whatever their circumstances, everyone should be able to count on the state for enough to live decently, through benefits, pensions or public services.
- Strongly: War does not strengthen a nation's character.
- Strongly: Being powerful does not mean a country should bring more land within its borders.
- Strongly: The government should let its political opponents organise, speak and compete for power.
- Strongly: Rapid economic development does not justify temporary restrictions on political freedom.
- Strongly: Political authority does not ultimately come from God.
- Strongly: Naturalized citizens may hold public office as well as people born in the country.
- Strongly: A socialist state with hostile neighbours need not build up its state power.
- Strongly: The leader should not bypass political intermediaries in dealing with the people.
- Strongly: A country may leave other nations to choose their own political systems.
- Strongly: The law should treat everyone as an equal, whatever their birth, sex, race or status.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not go with sharing its religion.
- Strongly: Most of the average difference in ability between racial groups does not come from genes.
- Strongly: Minority groups are not, as groups, secretly plotting to harm the nation.
- Strongly: The state should not steer people of the majority group toward settling in regions where minorities predominate.
- Strongly: Looking after your own interests is not a moral good in itself.
- Strongly: At least some revolutions have been justified.
- Strongly: News media should decide for themselves what they publish, whoever holds power.
- Strongly: No party's ideology should give it an exclusive right to lead the state.
- Strongly: A state with a state-owned planned economy should not be defended against capitalist restoration under a ruling bureaucracy.
- Strongly: Religious conversion should be free of legal restriction.
- Strongly: The armed forces may be controlled by someone other than the governing party's leadership.
- Strongly: Industrial society has done at least as much good as harm to humanity.
- Strongly: Population growth does not mainly drive lasting poverty.
- Strongly: There is no deliberate plan behind immigration aimed at replacing the native population.
- Strongly: People of different races should not be discouraged from forming a family together, including through marriage and children.
- Strongly: Publicly insulting a religion's sacred beliefs should be left outside the criminal law.
- Strongly: No state may force a minority out of the country, however hostile it judges that minority to be.
- Strongly: Some areas of life should remain outside state direction.
- Strongly: Private owners' choice of whom they deal with should be subject to some restrictions.
- Strongly: No society has the right to rule another for its supposed improvement, however advanced it is.
- Strongly: Women should be able to vote and stand for office on the same terms as men.
- Strongly: The vote keeps a government in check at least as well as being able to leave the country does.
- Strongly: A market economy is incompatible with socialism under communist-party leadership.
- Strongly: Adults may marry across religions without legal restriction.
- Strongly: Government should have other tasks besides protecting people from physical violence.
- Strongly: Public policy should not be used to reduce the passing on of inherited disabilities.
- Strongly: Belonging to a religious minority is no ground for shoppers to stay away from a shop.
- Strongly: Great powers should have no right to send troops against allied governments' wishes for the purpose of preserving those countries' political systems.
- Strongly: Political authority need not rest on oaths of loyalty sworn to a lord.
- Strongly: Voting should not be limited to members of one ethnic group.
- Strongly: Killing another person can be right in self-defence or in defence of others.
- Strongly: Overseas territories need not be run mainly for the ruling country's economic benefit.
- Strongly: Failure to govern under religious law does not justify armed overthrow of a ruler.
- Strongly: The holder of the highest state office need not be treated as holy.
- Strongly: Taking part in politics is at least as good a way to live as living privately away from public affairs.
- Strongly: People without property should also have the right to vote.
- Strongly: State schools need not steer pupils away from belief in God.
- Strongly: Public spaces such as schools and facilities should not be separated by race under the law.
- Strongly: Women may go out in public without any legal duty to cover fully.
- Strongly: Final authority over a state's laws need not belong to its most senior religious scholars.
- Strongly: The Holocaust happened as historians describe it.
- Strongly: People must be free to leave their religion without legal penalty.
- Strongly: Suspected drug dealers should never be put to death without a trial.
- Strongly: Farmers should have the legal freedom to leave the estates they work.
- Leans: Political power should rest on councils elected in workplaces in place of parliaments.
- Leans: Political change should replace the existing administrative and coercive institutions with new forms of organization, rather than put new leaders in charge of the old apparatus.
- Leans: Socialism in a single country will not endure without successful socialist revolutions in other countries.
- Leans: Historical change comes mainly from changes in how society produces and exchanges goods.
- Leans: Laws, police and government mainly serve the interests of whoever owns the economy and holds power.
- Leans: Western political institutions are suitable for every civilization.
- Leans: The political goal should be victory over communism ahead of accommodation with it.
- Leans: Countries that feel dominated by Western powers may handle their relations with them separately.
- Leans: Communist one-party regimes should be condemned as severely as fascist regimes.
- Leans: Employees should have voting rights in the management of large companies.
- Leans: Wage work cuts people off from the meaning and creativity of what they make.
- Leans: Businesses should belong to the people who work in them, for example as cooperatives.
- Leans: Having wealth does not by itself create a duty to help those who are worse off.
- Leans: A general collapse of capitalism is unavoidable.
- Leans: Society should follow a third course beyond capitalism and communism.
- Leans: Production should be organised to provide what people need, instead of being organised around what yields a profit.
- Leans: Workers in the same industry should organise together regardless of their particular trade, replacing separate craft unions.
- Leans: Industries such as energy, rail and utilities should be owned by the state or public bodies, not private companies.
- Leans: My country may keep a military no stronger than its rivals'.
- Leans: Government should serve people's good while respecting each person as more than an instrument of the state or community.
- Leans: My country should stay neutral and join neither of the opposing great-power alliances.
- Leans: Whether a policy fits an ideology should count independently of its results.
- Leans: Capitalism built the productive power and wealth that later and better societies rest on.
- Leans: Society should take active steps to make up for the harm done by past racial injustices.
- Leans: Political freedom can last without economic freedom.
- Leans: Society may be changed in large, rapid steps.
- Leans: People are entitled to resist a ruler's unconstitutional exercise of power.
- Leans: Each country's communist party should decide its strategy for socialism without taking orders from another country's party.
- Leans: People should have a direct role in making decisions where they work, live and study, rather than having those decisions made entirely for them.
- Leans: Society needs government of some kind.
- Leans: Being free requires having the practical resources to act on one's choices, such as an adequate livelihood.
- Leans: A workers' state does not need to suppress the old ruling class, even for a time.
- Leans: Political independence means little unless the economic and property system is also transformed.
- Leans: People may live and work outside communities that own their property together.
- Leans: Meeting poor people's needs should be the first consideration in public policy.
- Leans: Racial groups should not each organise to defend distinct political interests of their own.
- Leans: Small, informal, trust-based groups should not take the place of lasting parties, unions and federations in political action.
- Leans: An economy directed by a central plan is not capable of working better than one directed by market exchange.
- Leans: Class struggle does not continue under socialism.
- Leans: Political violence is sometimes justified.
- Leans: A people with a shared national identity is entitled to its own self-governing state.
- Leans: Workers do not need a disciplined revolutionary party to lead them.
- Leans: Being the first to use force can be right, depending on what it is meant to achieve.
- Leans: In an economy with common ownership of productive assets, people should still own their personal belongings.
- Leans: Individual farms should not give way to joint cultivation by groups of farmers.