Political Ideology Atlas · All ideologies · Take the test
Collectivist anarchism
Collectivist anarchism wants the state abolished and land, tools and capital held collectively by workers' associations, federated from the bottom up. Each worker is rewarded according to the labour done rather than according to need, which distinguishes it from anarcho-communism. It looks to trade unions and direct action, and to a popular revolution, as the means, and rejects both parliamentary politics and a Marxist workers' state.
What it stands for
- Society would be better off without governments at all.
- A people's connection to its ancestral land is not spiritual.
- Political change should replace the existing administrative and coercive institutions with new forms of organization, rather than put new leaders in charge of the old apparatus.
- The fact that something is law is not, by itself, a moral reason to obey it.
- A state has no responsibility for the welfare of its national communities across neighbouring borders.
- People should live and work in communities that own land and goods together and govern themselves.
Key figures
- Mikhail Bakunin: Founder of collectivist anarchism and rival of Marx in the First International
- James Guillaume: Jura Federation collectivist who outlined a post-capitalist distribution system
Closest ideologies
- Magonism (93% match)
- Anarcho-Communism (93% match)
- Anarcho-Syndicalism (92% match)
- Anarchist synthesis (92% match)
- Social anarchism (92% match)
People closest to it
- Emma Goldman (90% alike)
- Mikhail Bakunin (85% alike)
- William Morris (84% alike)
- Peter Kropotkin (84% alike)
- Noam Chomsky (84% alike)
Key positions
- Strongly: Society would be better off without governments at all.
- Strongly: A people's connection to its ancestral land is not spiritual.
- Strongly: Political change should replace the existing administrative and coercive institutions with new forms of organization, rather than put new leaders in charge of the old apparatus.
- Strongly: The fact that something is law is not, by itself, a moral reason to obey it.
- Strongly: A state has no responsibility for the welfare of its national communities across neighbouring borders.
- Strongly: People should live and work in communities that own land and goods together and govern themselves.
- Strongly: Schools should not cultivate patriotic feeling, meaning loyalty to and pride in the nation.
- Strongly: A healthy society does not depend on the traditional family, such as a married mother and father raising their children.
- Strongly: The state should not require immigrants to learn the language of the country they settle in.
- Strongly: Remembering those who die for the nation need not go beyond ordinary civic thanks.
- Strongly: Owners' profit is value taken from workers' labor.
- Strongly: A nation's identity does not run in unbroken continuity from its ancient origins to the present.
- Strongly: Cooperation between employers and workers should not come before conflict where their interests differ.
- Strongly: People seeking political change should act directly—for example, with strikes, boycotts or occupations—instead of pursuing change through elections and parliaments.
- Strongly: Land claimed as a historic homeland may be given up in exchange for peace.
- Strongly: The government may leave it to investors to decide which industries receive investment.
- Strongly: The country may allow more immigration than strict limits would permit.
- Strongly: Parties that seek to abolish a country's constitutional order should be free to organize.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not tie a person's life to a sacred community that goes on after their death.
- Strongly: Military service should always be voluntary.
- Strongly: Government should maintain a strict institutional separation from religion.
- Strongly: The state should not restrict money that foreign donors give to charities, campaign groups, the press and universities.
- Strongly: The nation does not need a radical rebirth to overcome decadence.
- Strongly: The state should be barred from executing people convicted of the gravest crimes, such as terrorism.
- Strongly: Working together internationally should count at least as much as my country's own priorities.
- Strongly: Religious values and institutions should not have a major part in shaping laws, schools and public life.
- Strongly: State schools should not teach religion.
- Strongly: Farmers should not be given state protection against swings in the prices they receive.
- Strongly: Trade unions should control their own affairs without state direction.
- Strongly: Property need not be spread among many small owners.
- Strongly: Businesses should belong to the people who work in them, for example as cooperatives.
- Strongly: Allied countries are free to decide for themselves whether to help one that is attacked.
- Strongly: Having wealth does not by itself create a duty to help those who are worse off.
- Strongly: The directly elected parliament should be a legislature's only chamber.
- Strongly: A country does not have the right to stop a region becoming independent by using its military.
- Strongly: Government surveillance is not acceptable, even to prevent terrorism.
- Strongly: Children of citizens are not the only ones who should be citizens at birth.
- Strongly: People outside state forces should also be allowed to bear arms.
- Strongly: The state should treat all streams and interpretations of a religion equally under the law.
- Strongly: Whoever uses land or resources owes the rest of society a share of their value.
- Strongly: The economy should not combine mainly private markets with government support for people who cannot meet their basic needs.
- Strongly: Formal press freedom is hollow when wealth decides who can actually be heard.
- Strongly: Real command of the military may rest with someone other than the head of state.
- Strongly: A head of state may take a side in party politics.
- Strongly: Serious repeat offenders should not necessarily face mandatory minimum sentences.
- Strongly: Non-citizens should also be eligible for welfare benefits.
- Strongly: Society may be changed in large, rapid steps.
- Strongly: Countries within one civilization may remain politically separate.
- Strongly: Workers' solidarity with workers in other countries should count at least as much as solidarity with their own nation.
- Strongly: Parties and offices should cut across religious lines.
- Strongly: Ordinary legal protections, such as the right not to be held without trial, should stay in force even in a national emergency.
- Strongly: A country can get through deadlock among its institutions without a leader who overrides them.
- Strongly: You can't reach a free, fair society by unfree or unfair means.
- Strongly: A person loses freedom from being at another person's mercy, even if that power is never exercised.
- Strongly: How someone turns out is shaped more by upbringing, society and experience than by the traits they are born with.
- Strongly: Immigrants should qualify for citizenship with less than ten years of residence.
- Strongly: Owners' rights to their property need not be protected against being overridden for public goals.
- Strongly: The law should impose no restrictions on strikes.
- Strongly: Government should rely at least as much on legal enforcement as on its rulers' moral example.
- Strongly: A country should not be ready to use military force abroad without UN Security Council authorization.
- Strongly: Workers are better off for having labor unions.
- Strongly: Ethnic diversity does not weaken a society's ability to hold together.
- Strongly: People should have a direct role in making decisions where they work, live and study, rather than having those decisions made entirely for them.
- Strongly: A wife should be able to end the marriage even when her husband refuses.
- Strongly: In law, a country's traditional national church should rank no higher than other religious bodies.
- Strongly: Politics is not best understood as a contest between spiritual good and evil.
- Strongly: Peoples who share an ethnic heritage, such as the Slavic peoples, should not come together in one state.
- Strongly: Being free requires having the practical resources to act on one's choices, such as an adequate livelihood.
- Strongly: The general public should have at least as much say in policy as experts.
- Strongly: Political independence means little unless the economic and property system is also transformed.
- Strongly: Nobody should hold a special rank by birth, such as a noble title, a hereditary crown or a caste position, or the special rights attached to one.
- Strongly: A nation does not need one main ethnic group: it can be made up of people of many ancestries.
- Strongly: Young people should not be organised into uniformed, drilled groups that prepare them to serve the nation.
- Strongly: Wages need not be set through negotiating bodies that the state officially recognizes.
- Strongly: Publicly honouring a national leader as the personification of the nation is not acceptable.
- Strongly: Spouses should make marital decisions as equals.
- Strongly: No one is better suited by nature to govern than anyone else.
- Strongly: Restoring a lost social order does not matter more than pursuing progress.
- Strongly: Other things drive humanity forward at least as much as rivalry and conflict between peoples.
- Strongly: Even a purely ceremonial head of state should not hold the position by birth.
- Strongly: The law should not assign different roles in public life on the basis of sex.
- Strongly: Land does not belong to whoever first puts it to use.
- Strongly: Racial groups should not each organise to defend distinct political interests of their own.
- Strongly: The great religions need not share a single underlying truth.
- Strongly: Very large concentrations of wealth threaten a free society.
- Strongly: My country should not send weapons to foreign insurgents, whatever it thinks of the governments they fight.
- Strongly: The holy scripture of one's faith is not God's own error-free word.
- Strongly: Leading roles in a country's economy should not depend on belonging to the majority national group.
- Strongly: An economy directed by a central plan is not capable of working better than one directed by market exchange.
- Strongly: War does not strengthen a nation's character.
- Strongly: Political violence is sometimes justified.
- Strongly: Income from useful work should be rewarded ahead of income from merely owning property.
- Strongly: Being powerful does not mean a country should bring more land within its borders.
- Strongly: The government should let its political opponents organise, speak and compete for power.
- Strongly: A national development strategy should not accept some regions growing wealthy ahead of the rest.
- Strongly: Political authority does not ultimately come from God.
- Strongly: A socialist state with hostile neighbours need not build up its state power.
- Strongly: The leader should not bypass political intermediaries in dealing with the people.
- Strongly: A country may leave other nations to choose their own political systems.
- Strongly: A mother country and its colonies may trade with the outside world.
- Strongly: State pensions funded by current workers' contributions should stay in place rather than be replaced by privately managed individual accounts.
- Strongly: Governments should give no subsidies, licences or protections that favour firms close to them.
- Strongly: The law should treat everyone as an equal, whatever their birth, sex, race or status.
- Strongly: In an economy with common ownership of productive assets, people should still own their personal belongings.
- Strongly: A government needs more than fair elections to be democratic.
- Strongly: Being the first to use force can be right, depending on what it is meant to achieve.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not go with sharing its religion.
- Strongly: Most of the average difference in ability between racial groups does not come from genes.
- Strongly: Someone who actually governs a state should not hand that power on to their own child.
- Strongly: Workers do not need a disciplined revolutionary party to lead them.
- Strongly: Minority groups are not, as groups, secretly plotting to harm the nation.
- Strongly: Laws should not be required to follow religious texts.
- Strongly: A country may make its laws with no formal advisory role for traditional chiefs.
- Strongly: At least some revolutions have been justified.
- Strongly: News media should decide for themselves what they publish, whoever holds power.
- Strongly: No party's ideology should give it an exclusive right to lead the state.
- Strongly: A state with a state-owned planned economy should not be defended against capitalist restoration under a ruling bureaucracy.
- Strongly: Religious conversion should be free of legal restriction.
- Strongly: Population growth does not mainly drive lasting poverty.
- Strongly: Publicly insulting a religion's sacred beliefs should be left outside the criminal law.
- Strongly: Some areas of life should remain outside state direction.
- Strongly: Private owners' choice of whom they deal with should be subject to some restrictions.
- Strongly: No society has the right to rule another for its supposed improvement, however advanced it is.
- Strongly: A market economy is incompatible with socialism under communist-party leadership.
- Strongly: A workers' state does not need to suppress the old ruling class, even for a time.
- Strongly: Adults may marry across religions without legal restriction.
- Strongly: The slaughter of cattle should be legal.
- Strongly: The ruler should be subject to the country's laws.
- Strongly: Government should have other tasks besides protecting people from physical violence.
- Strongly: Belonging to a religious minority is no ground for shoppers to stay away from a shop.
- Strongly: Voters of different religious communities may all vote in the same elections.
- Strongly: Voting should not be limited to members of one ethnic group.
- Strongly: Killing another person can be right in self-defence or in defence of others.
- Strongly: Taking part in politics is at least as good a way to live as living privately away from public affairs.
- Strongly: A weaker state need not formally treat a stronger power as its superior.
- Strongly: People without property should also have the right to vote.
- Strongly: Public spaces such as schools and facilities should not be separated by race under the law.
- Strongly: People must be free to leave their religion without legal penalty.
- Strongly: Humanity would gain nothing by going back to living off hunting and gathering.
- Strongly: Farmers should have the legal freedom to leave the estates they work.
- Leans: A country can and should do without a standing military.
- Leans: Police forces should be abolished and replaced with other ways of keeping people safe.
- Leans: Keeping a nation's inherited culture alive, including its language, customs and traditions, is not important.
- Leans: In the long run people should be free to live and work in any country.
- Leans: Political power should rest on councils elected in workplaces in place of parliaments.
- Leans: Individual soldiers and conscripts have a duty to refuse to fight in state wars.
- Leans: Religion gives people a false consolation for hardship in their material lives.
- Leans: Farming should be organized as joint cultivation by groups of farmers instead of separate individual farm operations.
- Leans: Having a shared national identity does not by itself entitle a people to its own self-governing state.
- Leans: Grown children are free to decide for themselves whether to care for parents in need.
- Leans: Politics need not concern itself with people's spiritual needs.
- Leans: Private property does not need to serve the common good to be justified.
- Leans: History is mainly driven by conflict between economic classes.
- Leans: Towns and cities should link through councils whose delegates coordinate and administer what local assemblies decide, without making policy themselves.
- Leans: People should lose their right to a plot of land when they no longer use it.
- Leans: Historical change comes mainly from changes in how society produces and exchanges goods.
- Leans: Religious teaching and institutions are a main reason women have been held down.
- Leans: A people divided by an imposed border may remain in separate states.
- Leans: Serving the nation does not mean serving its working people.
- Leans: People should gain political representation through social bodies such as families, local communities and occupational associations instead of political parties.
- Leans: Where they conflict, evidence and reasoning should count for more than faith, God, revelation or scripture.
- Leans: Defense should rest with armed ordinary citizens, not a standing force.
- Leans: The government may spend public money without first getting its budget approved by an elected legislature.
- Leans: Every religious leadership role open to men should be open to women under the same eligibility rules.
- Leans: One worker's pay need not cover the living needs of that worker's family.
- Leans: After members debate and adopt a party decision, those who opposed it should not have to help implement it.
- Leans: Democracy is not the best form of government when voters choose badly.
- Leans: Those who inherit a large fortune should hand over a big share of it in tax.
- Leans: The farmers who work large estates should take ownership from the landowners, with the transfer compulsory if owners refuse.
- Leans: Industries such as energy, rail and utilities do not need to be publicly owned.
- Leans: A woman who has sex outside marriage is not doing anything wrong.
- Leans: Politics should give compromises among competing groups at least as much weight as a single common good identified by reasoning.
- Leans: Wage work cuts people off from the meaning and creativity of what they make.
- Leans: Political power may be concentrated in one body.
- Leans: Women's subordination is tied to how the economy is organised, so reform of laws and attitudes is not enough.
- Leans: Inherited religious teachings may stay as handed down, without being rethought for present conditions.
- Leans: The ruling class stays in power mainly through people going along with its ideas.
- Leans: Council homes may stay in public hands without tenants having a right to buy them.
- Leans: A general collapse of capitalism is unavoidable.
- Leans: What things are worth comes from the work put into them.
- Leans: The state need not guarantee work to everyone who wants a job.
- Leans: Laws, institutions and customs still favor men over women.
- Leans: Areas where an ethnic minority makes up most of the population should be able to run many of their own affairs within the state.
- Leans: People able to work should get welfare benefits only in return for some work, such as a job or a work scheme.
- Leans: Foreign powers sometimes have a right to intervene in a country's internal affairs.
- Leans: Political decisions should rest with the smallest local community able to handle them, with wider authorities handling matters that need a wider reach.
- Leans: Without workers' own political power, state ownership is not socialism.
- Leans: The national legislature should not be able to take back powers given to regions on its own.
- Leans: Workers may be represented through the parties already in place.
- Leans: Some knowledge is neutral.
- Leans: The left-right division in politics remains meaningful.
- Leans: State schools need not steer pupils away from belief in God.
- Leans: Seats may be allocated in ways that do not follow parties' shares of the vote closely.
- Leans: Another body may have the final say over what the legislature passes.
- Leans: The state should not make one language the only common language of government, schooling and public life at the cost of limiting others.
- Leans: People are entitled to resist a ruler's unconstitutional exercise of power.
- Leans: Whether a distribution of wealth is just does not depend only on how it came about.
- Leans: Recruitment to the civil service should not depend on competitive examinations.
- Leans: Social duty should not take the place of material rewards as the main reason people work.
- Leans: An electorate should choose the head of state, either directly or through elected representatives.
- Leans: In the society we should aim for, a person's share of goods may depend on things besides their needs.
- Leans: Collecting taxes does not in itself amount to stealing people's money.
- Leans: A country may keep all its decisions in its own hands rather than pooling them with other nations.
- Leans: Some decisions should bind people who have not consented to them.
- Leans: Spreading democracy does not bring peace.
- Leans: Meeting poor people's needs should be the first consideration in public policy.
- Leans: In the long run people should still produce and share using money.
- Leans: Work may stay divided into separate specialized jobs held by different people.
- Leans: Rulers have a right to rule only because the people they rule have agreed to it.
- Leans: Most people in political office look after themselves first and the public second.
- Leans: Small, informal, trust-based groups should not take the place of lasting parties, unions and federations in political action.
- Leans: Looking after your own interests is not a moral good in itself.
- Leans: An armed minority's actions are incapable of bringing about the conditions for a broader revolutionary uprising.
- Leans: Businesses gain too much influence over government policy from their lobbying.
- Leans: Groups have rights of their own.