Political Ideology Atlas · All ideologies · Take the test
Reactionary modernism
Reactionary modernism, a term coined by Jeffrey Herf, names the Weimar-era German right's fusion of enthusiasm for modern technology, industry and war with rejection of the Enlightenment, liberalism and parliamentary democracy. Its thinkers wanted a strong, hierarchical, Volkisch national state that would harness machines and mass mobilisation in the service of myth, duty and national rebirth, and many were absorbed into or supported Nazism.
What it stands for
- Every part of life should be subject to state direction.
- The law may treat people differently according to such things as birth, sex, race and status.
- The leader should bypass parties and organised interest groups in dealing with the people.
- Only people born in the country should hold public office.
- The military should have a political role in protecting the constitution and public order, stepping in when they are threatened.
- Temporary limits on political freedom are justified to achieve rapid economic development.
Key figures
- Ernst Jünger: Writer whose total mobilisation and worker essays celebrated war and technology.
- Oswald Spengler: Philosopher of history who urged Prussian socialism and a technics-embracing Faustian West.
- Carl Schmitt: Jurist who justified dictatorship, the exception and the Nazi leader state.
Closest ideologies
- Palingenetic ultranationalism (93% match)
- Aryanism (92% match)
- Fascist mysticism (91% match)
- Positive Christianity (91% match)
- National Socialism (91% match)
People closest to it
- Adolf Hitler (90% alike)
- Benito Mussolini (90% alike)
- Joseph Goebbels (90% alike)
- Reinhard Heydrich (89% alike)
- Hermann Göring (89% alike)
Key positions
- Strongly: Every part of life should be subject to state direction.
- Strongly: The law may treat people differently according to such things as birth, sex, race and status.
- Strongly: The leader should bypass parties and organised interest groups in dealing with the people.
- Strongly: Only people born in the country should hold public office.
- Strongly: The military should have a political role in protecting the constitution and public order, stepping in when they are threatened.
- Strongly: Temporary limits on political freedom are justified to achieve rapid economic development.
- Strongly: The government should stop its political opponents from organising, speaking or competing for power.
- Strongly: War develops virtues in a nation, such as courage and discipline.
- Strongly: A person's sex should affect the public roles legally assigned to them.
- Strongly: Consent of the governed is not the only basis of legitimate political authority.
- Strongly: Rivalry and conflict between nations or peoples do more than anything else to drive humanity forward.
- Strongly: The presence of people belonging to the same nation gives a state a legitimate territorial claim outside its borders.
- Strongly: Some people are better suited by nature to govern.
- Strongly: It is acceptable to praise a national leader openly as the one who stands for the whole nation.
- Strongly: Officially recognized bodies representing employers and workers should negotiate wages together.
- Strongly: A nation should be mainly one ethnic people.
- Strongly: Rulers are not bound to act only under lasting, publicly known laws administered by recognised courts.
- Strongly: People should gain political representation through social bodies such as families, local communities and occupational associations instead of political parties.
- Strongly: People do not need a direct role in making decisions where they work, live and study.
- Strongly: A society holds together less well when its members belong to different ethnic groups.
- Strongly: A country should be ready to use military force abroad on its own judgment, even if the UN Security Council has not authorized it.
- Strongly: Innate nature shapes a person's character at least as much as their environment does.
- Strongly: The government may spend public money without first getting its budget approved by an elected legislature.
- Strongly: A ruler's unconstitutional acts do not give people a right to resist.
- Strongly: No moral truths hold across all cultures.
- Strongly: The country would benefit from a strong leader with the power to act despite deadlock among its political institutions.
- Strongly: A national emergency sometimes justifies temporarily withdrawing normal legal safeguards against people the government regards as internal enemies, such as protections against detention without trial.
- Strongly: Workers' solidarity with their own nation should take priority over solidarity with workers across borders.
- Strongly: Only citizens should be eligible for welfare benefits, including immigrants who have become citizens.
- Strongly: Society may deal with racial discrimination as it arises today without programs aimed at past wrongs.
- Strongly: Real authority to command the military should rest with the head of state.
- Strongly: A country should press its neighbour to give back land taken from it in an old war.
- Strongly: A society can be socialist without the working class itself holding political power.
- Strongly: At least some unjust laws impose a moral duty of obedience.
- Strongly: Democracy is not the best form of government when voters choose badly.
- Strongly: Collective goals can justify treating a person merely as a tool.
- Strongly: The political goal should be victory over communism ahead of accommodation with it.
- Strongly: My country's military strength should exceed that of its rivals.
- Strongly: People may want more than the fewest material things possible.
- Strongly: Laws, institutions and customs today do not systematically favor men over women.
- Strongly: Only children of citizens should be citizens at birth: being born in the country should not be enough.
- Strongly: A country has the right to stop a region becoming independent by using its military.
- Strongly: Political power may be concentrated in one body.
- Strongly: Women's equality can be fully achieved without transforming the economic system.
- Strongly: Government should not be bound by a written bill of rights protected against easy amendment by ordinary majorities.
- Strongly: Wealthy countries have no duty to give substantial aid to the world's poor abroad.
- Strongly: Workers should not have democratic voting rights in the management of large companies.
- Strongly: Society should follow a third course beyond capitalism and communism.
- Strongly: When national priorities conflict with working together internationally, my country should choose its own priorities.
- Strongly: The worst crimes can be punished by death.
- Strongly: The nation has decayed and must be reborn.
- Strongly: The state should limit or screen money that foreign donors give to charities, campaign groups, the press and universities.
- Strongly: Communist one-party states should not receive the same condemnation as fascist states.
- Strongly: The state should give families money to have more children, such as through payments and tax breaks.
- Strongly: Past abuses by a state's security forces may be put behind it without anyone answering for them in court.
- Strongly: The government should be able to require citizens to serve in the military.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation ties a person's life to a sacred community that goes on after their death.
- Strongly: Cultural life inside a state should not be placed under the control of each national minority.
- Strongly: Armed forces may sometimes be used for purposes beyond defending the country against attack.
- Strongly: Armed forces may refuse to let gay people serve openly.
- Strongly: What you owe your community matters more than your personal rights.
- Strongly: The government should steer investment into industries it sees as key to the country's future.
- Strongly: Tackling oppression does not require a combined approach to its overlapping forms, such as racism, sexism and class oppression.
- Strongly: Ideas of what men and women are like do not come mostly from culture.
- Strongly: A democratic constitution need not be founded on an explicit rejection of fascism.
- Strongly: Political freedom can last without economic freedom.
- Strongly: Society may be changed in large, rapid steps.
- Strongly: A region need not keep most of the tax money it raises for itself.
- Strongly: A country's constitution should prevail when it conflicts with international legal obligations.
- Strongly: The state should stop foreign buyers from taking over key national businesses.
- Strongly: Seats may be allocated in ways that do not follow parties' shares of the vote closely.
- Strongly: Another body may have the final say over what the legislature passes.
- Strongly: Elected representatives may serve out their terms without voters being able to remove them early.
- Strongly: Employers and workers should treat each other as partners whose cooperation comes before conflict, even where their interests differ.
- Strongly: Society should use modern technology together with revived values inherited from its ancestors.
- Strongly: In the society we should aim for, a person's share of goods may depend on things besides their needs.
- Strongly: Profit made from owning businesses does not come from exploiting the workers who produce it.
- Strongly: Capitalism does not inevitably cause wars between great powers.
- Strongly: It is not true that communities should be free to choose their own economic arrangements with no fixed blueprint for a free society's economy.
- Strongly: Where they conflict, religious faith should count for at least as much as evidence and reasoning.
- Strongly: Transgender people's legal gender should not be based on their gender identity.
- Strongly: People who give their lives for the nation deserve to be remembered as martyrs, with reverence beyond ordinary thanks.
- Strongly: Political institutions developed in the West are not a suitable model for every civilization.
- Strongly: The subordination of women and human mastery over nature can be understood as separate matters.
- Strongly: Conclusions from groups of citizens chosen at random should not contribute to decisions on major public issues.
- Strongly: The people who own the economy and hold power are not the ones the state mainly serves.
- Strongly: Rules need not set equal numbers of women and men on public bodies.
- Strongly: A country may keep a region that wants to leave.
- Strongly: A country may keep all its decisions in its own hands rather than pooling them with other nations.
- Strongly: Schools should cultivate patriotic feeling: loyalty to and pride in the nation, expressed for example through respect for its flag and anthem.
- Strongly: The law should not extend marriage to same-sex couples.
- Strongly: People may live and work outside communities that own their property together.
- Strongly: A people split by an imposed border should be brought together in a single state.
- Strongly: Spreading democracy does not bring peace.
- Strongly: International criminal trials should not be required for every political leader responsible for atrocities.
- Strongly: Society need not promote ways of living that differ from custom.
- Strongly: Historical change does not come mainly from changes in how society produces and exchanges goods.
- Strongly: The state may restrict what adults do for reasons other than preventing harm to others.
- Strongly: Being the law gives a rule a moral claim to be obeyed.
- Strongly: Equality of outcomes should not be society's goal.
- Strongly: Population growth may be left to run its course.
- Strongly: Other forces move history at least as much as conflict between classes does.
- Strongly: Member states should keep the final decision on whether to follow UN decisions.
- Strongly: At most half of workers in wealthy countries benefit from the exploitation of poorer countries.
- Strongly: Class struggle does not continue under socialism.
- Strongly: Economic growth should not be limited for the sake of the environment.
- Strongly: Unequal results between racial groups do not by themselves make a policy discriminatory.
- Strongly: Political violence is sometimes justified.
- Strongly: A people's connection to its ancestral land is spiritual, beyond practical interests or ordinary affection.
- Strongly: Groups have rights of their own.
- Strongly: School history should mostly tell the story of the student's own nation.
- Strongly: Citizens should not be permitted to choose someone else to cast their votes in a policy area, with separate choices for different areas.
- Strongly: A government needs more than fair elections to be democratic.
- Strongly: Being the first to use force can be right, depending on what it is meant to achieve.
- Strongly: Looking after your own interests is not a moral good in itself.
- Strongly: Soldiers and conscripts need not refuse to fight when their state goes to war.
- Strongly: At least some revolutions have been justified.
- Strongly: Political power may rest on something other than workplace-elected councils.
- Strongly: Countries may keep controls on who enters and settles, even in the long run.
- Strongly: Keeping a nation's inherited culture alive, including its language, customs and traditions, matters.
- Strongly: In a war between great powers, workers need not seek their own government's defeat.
- Strongly: Industrial society has done at least as much good as harm to humanity.
- Strongly: Work may stay divided into separate specialized jobs held by different people.
- Strongly: In the long run people should still produce and share using money.
- Strongly: Each country should hold ultimate authority over its natural resources, without foreign interests controlling them.
- Strongly: Marriage should retain legal recognition.
- Strongly: The vote keeps a government in check at least as well as being able to leave the country does.
- Strongly: Some decisions should bind people who have not consented to them.
- Strongly: A workers' state does not need to suppress the old ruling class, even for a time.
- Strongly: Public offices may be filled by methods other than drawing lots.
- Strongly: Police forces should continue to exist.
- Strongly: Society needs government of some kind.
- Strongly: Countries should keep their armed forces.
- Strongly: The slaughter of cattle should be legal.
- Strongly: Government should have other tasks besides protecting people from physical violence.
- Strongly: Collecting taxes does not in itself amount to stealing people's money.
- Strongly: Renting out housing should be permitted in at least some circumstances.
- Strongly: Taking part in politics is at least as good a way to live as living privately away from public affairs.
- Strongly: Courts need not be handed over to private businesses.
- Strongly: Final authority over a state's laws need not belong to its most senior religious scholars.
- Strongly: People must be free to leave their religion without legal penalty.
- Strongly: Humanity would gain nothing by going back to living off hunting and gathering.
- Leans: Law should require people of different races to use separate public spaces, such as schools and public facilities.
- Leans: Only members of one racial or ethnic group should have the right to vote.
- Leans: Shoppers should choose to stay away from shops whose owners belong to a particular religious minority.
- Leans: Public policy, such as sterilization or incentives, should reduce the passing on of inherited disabilities.
- Leans: The ruler should not be bound by the country's laws, including those made by that ruler and by earlier ones.
- Leans: Temporary rule by a more developed society is justified when it helps the ruled to progress.
- Leans: People of different races should be discouraged from forming a family together, whether through marriage or having children.
- Leans: Same-sex relations between consenting adults should be punishable by law.
- Leans: The people in power should decide what the country's news media publish.
- Leans: The state should encourage people of the majority group to move into areas where minority groups are in the majority.
- Leans: A minority group is working in secret to harm the nation.
- Leans: An armed minority's actions are capable of bringing about conditions that enable a broader revolutionary uprising.
- Leans: The mother country and its colonies should meet their economic needs within their own bloc instead of trading with the outside world.
- Leans: A socialist state with hostile countries all around it should work to make its state power stronger.
- Leans: A powerful country should bring more land within its borders.
- Leans: Art, poetry and stories that harm people's moral character should be censored.
- Leans: Once the national majority has decided, public institutions, including courts and independent bodies, should not limit its decision.
- Leans: Public policy need not put the needs of the poor ahead of other concerns.
- Leans: Special ranks held by birth, such as noble titles and hereditary crowns, may continue to exist.
- Leans: Specialists should have more weight in decisions than public opinion.
- Leans: Labor unions do not necessarily make workers better off.
- Leans: The government should have authority over religious institutions' internal affairs.
- Leans: Government should depend more on leaders setting a good example than on enforcing laws with penalties.
- Leans: The head of state should not have to be chosen by election.
- Leans: People should work mainly out of responsibility to society and a shared purpose, with personal material rewards playing a secondary role.
- Leans: Voters themselves should elect the head of state, without an intermediary body selecting the officeholder.
- Leans: People seeking political change should act directly—for example, with strikes, boycotts or occupations—instead of pursuing change through elections and parliaments.
- Leans: Defense should rest with armed ordinary citizens, not a standing force.
- Leans: Unused arbitrary power over a person does not itself reduce that person's freedom.
- Leans: The state should make one language the only common language of government, schooling and public life, limiting the use of others.
- Leans: Land that a state declares its own against its people's will is not illegally occupied by that state.
- Leans: Elected officials should serve out their full terms.
- Leans: Dividing politics into left and right no longer makes sense.
- Leans: Society should push new technology forward faster, even where it overturns established institutions.
- Leans: What gets treated as fact or expert knowledge reflects the interests of whoever has power, not a neutral search for truth.
- Leans: The nation's figurehead should be non-partisan and belong to everyone.
- Leans: Whether citizens may see government information can be left to the government to decide.
- Leans: A government should sometimes be entitled to rewrite or end such a treaty without the resident nation's consent.
- Leans: Many political decisions should rest with national or wider authorities, even where a smaller community could handle them.
- Leans: A president should be free to stand for re-election as many times as they like.
- Leans: Science and technology will fix most of what goes wrong for people.
- Leans: Industries such as energy, rail and utilities do not need to be publicly owned.
- Leans: Most goods need not be produced close to their place of consumption.
- Leans: People do not have full ownership of their own bodies.
- Leans: Transfers of wealth to richer countries do not explain poor countries' continuing poverty.
- Leans: Production should not be reorganised around what people need in place of what yields a profit.
- Leans: Tax rates should not rise steeply with income.
- Leans: Land stays in the hands of citizens; foreigners may not buy it.
- Leans: What things are worth does not come from the work put into them.
- Leans: Governments should sometimes withhold the records explaining their decisions.
- Leans: Property need not be spread among many small owners.
- Leans: Rich people have an obligation to help those worse off than they are.
- Leans: Businesses need not belong to the people who work in them.
- Leans: Work under capitalism does not alienate people from their own creative activity.
- Leans: Emigrating to establish a homeland should take at least as much priority as seeking equal rights where persecuted minorities live.
- Leans: Living in the countryside does more for a person's moral wellbeing than living in a city.
- Leans: Politics should prioritise a single common good identified by reasoning over compromises among organised interests.
- Leans: Agreements between competing firms, price-fixing included, need not be outlawed.
- Leans: Abortion should be illegal in most cases.
- Leans: People able to work should get welfare benefits only in return for some work, such as a job or a work scheme.
- Leans: Foreign powers sometimes have a right to intervene in a country's internal affairs.
- Leans: Large landed estates should not be compulsorily transferred to the people who farm them.
- Leans: Museums, libraries and other inherited culture should not be destroyed, even when they stand in the way of new creation.
- Leans: Heirs to large fortunes may keep most of what they inherit.
- Leans: A government should outlaw political parties that aim to do away with its constitutional order.
- Leans: My country should stay neutral and join neither of the opposing great-power alliances.
- Leans: Whether a policy fits an ideology should count independently of its results.
- Leans: Trade deals may leave out legally binding requirements protecting workers.
- Leans: Major laws should not be decided by direct votes of citizens.
- Leans: After members debate and adopt a party decision, every member should have to help implement it, including those who opposed it.
- Leans: A poor country should develop mainly with its own resources.
- Leans: Separate national currencies are at least as good for countries as a single shared one.
- Leans: Capitalist exchange does not make people's economic relationships look like relationships among the goods they trade.
- Leans: People without property should also have the right to vote.
- Leans: A weaker state need not formally treat a stronger power as its superior.
- Leans: Free trade does not benefit everyone in the long run.
- Leans: Religious minorities should not be exempt from general laws that burden their practice.
- Leans: Failure to govern under religious law does not justify armed overthrow of a ruler.
- Leans: An ancestral bond to a land gives a people a claim that outweighs the claims of other peoples who now live there.
- Leans: Hate speech should be legal.
- Leans: Some cultures are superior to others.
- Leans: Owners' rights to their property need not be protected against being overridden for public goals.
- Leans: Officials decide what gets made and who gets it at least as well as prices and competition do.
- Leans: The best constitution does not combine rule by the few with rule by the many.
- Leans: Adults may marry across religions without legal restriction.
- Leans: A healthy society depends on the traditional family, such as a married mother and father raising their children.
- Leans: The nation's cause and the cause of its ordinary working people are one and the same.
- Leans: Profit-making banks should not be replaced by user-owned banks charging only the costs of running the service.
- Leans: Private owners' choice of whom they deal with should be subject to some restrictions.
- Leans: Constantly seeking additional possessions is harmful overall, despite any benefits it brings.
- Leans: Publicly insulting a religion's sacred beliefs should be left outside the criminal law.
- Leans: There is no deliberate plan behind immigration aimed at replacing the native population.
- Leans: Population growth does not mainly drive lasting poverty.
- Leans: Lasting socialism in one country does not require socialist revolutions abroad.
- Leans: Families may keep the main responsibility for housework and childcare.
- Leans: A person's right to hold land need not end when they stop using it.
- Leans: Restoring a lost social order does not matter more than pursuing progress.
- Leans: Public school science classes may teach evolution on its own.
- Leans: Most people in political office look after themselves first and the public second.
- Leans: Private ownership is legitimate only insofar as it benefits society.
- Leans: Small, informal, trust-based groups should not take the place of lasting parties, unions and federations in political action.
- Leans: Armed resistance to a non-Muslim invasion of Muslim land is not a duty binding every Muslim.
- Leans: A people with a shared national identity is entitled to its own self-governing state.
- Leans: Laws should not be required to follow religious texts.
- Leans: Religion does not offer illusory comfort for material suffering.
- Leans: Lending money at interest should be legal.
- Leans: Belonging to the nation does not go with sharing its religion.
- Leans: State pensions funded by current workers' contributions should stay in place rather than be replaced by privately managed individual accounts.
- Leans: Individual farms should not give way to joint cultivation by groups of farmers.