Political Ideology Atlas · All ideologies · Take the test
Mutualism
Mutualism is the libertarian socialist market economy associated with Pierre-Joseph Proudhon. It holds that labour is the basis of property and value, treats rent, profit and non-nominal interest as exploitation, and would end them through free mutual credit and exchange at cost among artisans, peasants and worker-run associations. Government is to be dissolved into contracts between free groups in a decentralised federation.
What it stands for
- Society would be better off without governments at all.
- Even a single dissenter should be free from a decision they have refused.
- Society should aim for people to end up with broadly equal material conditions.
- The fact that something is law is not, by itself, a moral reason to obey it.
- Credit should come from banks owned by their users, charging only the costs of running the service, in place of profit-making banks.
- Schools should not cultivate patriotic feeling, meaning loyalty to and pride in the nation.
Key figures
- Pierre-Joseph Proudhon: Founding theorist of mutualism and author of What Is Property?
- Josiah Warren: American anarchist who developed the principle that cost is the limit of price
- Benjamin Tucker: American mutualist who named four monopolies of money, land, tariffs and patents
Closest ideologies
- Anarcho-Pacifism (88% match)
- Philosophical anarchism (88% match)
- Christian Anarchism (88% match)
- Syndicalism (87% match)
- Anarcho-Naturism (86% match)
People closest to it
- Leo Tolstoy (85% alike)
- Ted Kaczynski (84% alike)
- Jesse Ventura (81% alike)
- Theodor W. Adorno (81% alike)
- Rudolf Steiner (80% alike)
Key positions
- Strongly: Society would be better off without governments at all.
- Strongly: Even a single dissenter should be free from a decision they have refused.
- Strongly: Society should aim for people to end up with broadly equal material conditions.
- Strongly: The fact that something is law is not, by itself, a moral reason to obey it.
- Strongly: Credit should come from banks owned by their users, charging only the costs of running the service, in place of profit-making banks.
- Strongly: Schools should not cultivate patriotic feeling, meaning loyalty to and pride in the nation.
- Strongly: Remembering those who die for the nation need not go beyond ordinary civic thanks.
- Strongly: Communities should be free to choose their own economic arrangements, and a free society has no fixed blueprint for its economy.
- Strongly: Owners' profit is value taken from workers' labor.
- Strongly: Firms should compete in markets, but be owned by the people who work in them.
- Strongly: After members debate and adopt a party decision, those who opposed it should not have to help implement it.
- Strongly: The government may leave it to investors to decide which industries receive investment.
- Strongly: Industries such as energy, rail and utilities do not need to be publicly owned.
- Strongly: Government should maintain a strict institutional separation from religion.
- Strongly: The nation does not need a radical rebirth to overcome decadence.
- Strongly: Businesses should belong to the people who work in them, for example as cooperatives.
- Strongly: Property should belong to many people in small holdings.
- Strongly: What things are worth comes from the work put into them.
- Strongly: Society should follow a third course beyond capitalism and communism.
- Strongly: A country does not have the right to stop a region becoming independent by using its military.
- Strongly: My country may keep a military no stronger than its rivals'.
- Strongly: Political decisions should rest with the smallest local community able to handle them, with wider authorities handling matters that need a wider reach.
- Strongly: A country may accept its present border with a neighbour even if it lost land in an old war.
- Strongly: Real command of the military may rest with someone other than the head of state.
- Strongly: Serious repeat offenders should not necessarily face mandatory minimum sentences.
- Strongly: Major laws should not be decided by direct votes of citizens.
- Strongly: Workers' solidarity with workers in other countries should count at least as much as solidarity with their own nation.
- Strongly: Ordinary legal protections, such as the right not to be held without trial, should stay in force even in a national emergency.
- Strongly: A country can get through deadlock among its institutions without a leader who overrides them.
- Strongly: In the society we should aim for, a person's share of goods may depend on things besides their needs.
- Strongly: A country should not be ready to use military force abroad without UN Security Council authorization.
- Strongly: In law, a country's traditional national church should rank no higher than other religious bodies.
- Strongly: A former empire should claim no special ties, leadership or sphere of influence in its old territories.
- Strongly: Nobody should hold a special rank by birth, such as a noble title, a hereditary crown or a caste position, or the special rights attached to one.
- Strongly: A nation does not need one main ethnic group: it can be made up of people of many ancestries.
- Strongly: Young people should not be organised into uniformed, drilled groups that prepare them to serve the nation.
- Strongly: Publicly honouring a national leader as the personification of the nation is not acceptable.
- Strongly: No one is better suited by nature to govern than anyone else.
- Strongly: The presence of people of its nationality does not give a state a rightful claim to land beyond its borders.
- Strongly: Restoring a lost social order does not matter more than pursuing progress.
- Strongly: Rulers have a right to rule only because the people they rule have agreed to it.
- Strongly: Even a purely ceremonial head of state should not hold the position by birth.
- Strongly: Very large concentrations of wealth threaten a free society.
- Strongly: My country should not send weapons to foreign insurgents, whatever it thinks of the governments they fight.
- Strongly: The holy scripture of one's faith is not God's own error-free word.
- Strongly: Leading roles in a country's economy should not depend on belonging to the majority national group.
- Strongly: An economy directed by a central plan is not capable of working better than one directed by market exchange.
- Strongly: Income from useful work should be rewarded ahead of income from merely owning property.
- Strongly: Being powerful does not mean a country should bring more land within its borders.
- Strongly: The government should let its political opponents organise, speak and compete for power.
- Strongly: Rapid economic development does not justify temporary restrictions on political freedom.
- Strongly: Protecting the constitution should be left to civilian institutions, not the armed forces.
- Strongly: A national development strategy should not accept some regions growing wealthy ahead of the rest.
- Strongly: Political authority does not ultimately come from God.
- Strongly: Naturalized citizens may hold public office as well as people born in the country.
- Strongly: A socialist state with hostile neighbours need not build up its state power.
- Strongly: The leader should not bypass political intermediaries in dealing with the people.
- Strongly: A country may leave other nations to choose their own political systems.
- Strongly: A mother country and its colonies may trade with the outside world.
- Strongly: Elected governments need not leave monetary policy to central banks acting on their own.
- Strongly: Governments should give no subsidies, licences or protections that favour firms close to them.
- Strongly: Individual farms should not give way to joint cultivation by groups of farmers.
- Strongly: Belonging to the nation does not go with sharing its religion.
- Strongly: Most of the average difference in ability between racial groups does not come from genes.
- Strongly: Someone who actually governs a state should not hand that power on to their own child.
- Strongly: An armed minority's actions are incapable of bringing about the conditions for a broader revolutionary uprising.
- Strongly: Workers do not need a disciplined revolutionary party to lead them.
- Strongly: Minority groups are not, as groups, secretly plotting to harm the nation.
- Strongly: Laws should not be required to follow religious texts.
- Strongly: Islam is compatible with Western values.
- Strongly: A country may make its laws with no formal advisory role for traditional chiefs.
- Strongly: No party's ideology should give it an exclusive right to lead the state.
- Strongly: A state with a state-owned planned economy should not be defended against capitalist restoration under a ruling bureaucracy.
- Strongly: Religious conversion should be free of legal restriction.
- Strongly: The armed forces may be controlled by someone other than the governing party's leadership.
- Strongly: Public school science classes may teach evolution on its own.
- Strongly: Work may stay divided into separate specialized jobs held by different people.
- Strongly: Population growth does not mainly drive lasting poverty.
- Strongly: There is no deliberate plan behind immigration aimed at replacing the native population.
- Strongly: People of different races should not be discouraged from forming a family together, including through marriage and children.
- Strongly: Publicly insulting a religion's sacred beliefs should be left outside the criminal law.
- Strongly: No state may force a minority out of the country, however hostile it judges that minority to be.
- Strongly: Some areas of life should remain outside state direction.
- Strongly: No society has the right to rule another for its supposed improvement, however advanced it is.
- Strongly: A market economy is incompatible with socialism under communist-party leadership.
- Strongly: A workers' state does not need to suppress the old ruling class, even for a time.
- Strongly: The ruler should be subject to the country's laws.
- Strongly: Great powers should have no right to send troops against allied governments' wishes for the purpose of preserving those countries' political systems.
- Strongly: Political authority need not rest on oaths of loyalty sworn to a lord.
- Strongly: The holder of the highest state office need not be treated as holy.
- Strongly: A weaker state need not formally treat a stronger power as its superior.
- Strongly: State schools need not steer pupils away from belief in God.
- Strongly: Public spaces such as schools and facilities should not be separated by race under the law.
- Strongly: Women may go out in public without any legal duty to cover fully.
- Strongly: Final authority over a state's laws need not belong to its most senior religious scholars.
- Strongly: People must be free to leave their religion without legal penalty.
- Strongly: Suspected drug dealers should never be put to death without a trial.
- Strongly: Museums, libraries and other inherited culture should not be destroyed, even when they stand in the way of new creation.
- Strongly: Humanity would gain nothing by going back to living off hunting and gathering.
- Strongly: Farmers should have the legal freedom to leave the estates they work.
- Leans: No housing provider, including a private owner or the state, should charge rent for a home.
- Leans: A country can and should do without a standing military.
- Leans: Being able to leave the country keeps a government in check better than the vote does.
- Leans: Central banks should give way to a market in which people choose the money they use without a central bank controlling its supply.
- Leans: When rival great powers go to war, workers should work to make their own state lose.
- Leans: Keeping a nation's inherited culture alive, including its language, customs and traditions, is not important.
- Leans: Political power should rest on councils elected in workplaces in place of parliaments.
- Leans: Farms, factories and utilities belong to the town or city that uses them.
- Leans: Having a shared national identity does not by itself entitle a people to its own self-governing state.
- Leans: Violence is never an acceptable way to pursue political goals.
- Leans: Whoever first settles and works unowned land becomes its rightful owner.
- Leans: A person's sex should affect the public roles legally assigned to them.
- Leans: Political change should replace the existing administrative and coercive institutions with new forms of organization, rather than put new leaders in charge of the old apparatus.
- Leans: Towns and cities should link through councils whose delegates coordinate and administer what local assemblies decide, without making policy themselves.
- Leans: People should lose their right to a plot of land when they no longer use it.
- Leans: Historical change comes mainly from changes in how society produces and exchanges goods.
- Leans: Ideas and creative works should be free to copy, with no one holding a legal monopoly on them.
- Leans: People should gain political representation through social bodies such as families, local communities and occupational associations instead of political parties.
- Leans: Countries should hand part of their decision-making power to a union of nations, such as the European Union.
- Leans: Laws, police and government mainly serve the interests of whoever owns the economy and holds power.
- Leans: Prices and competition generally decide better than officials what gets made and who gets it.
- Leans: People seeking political change should act directly—for example, with strikes, boycotts or occupations—instead of pursuing change through elections and parliaments.
- Leans: Defense should rest with armed ordinary citizens, not a standing force.
- Leans: Foreign buyers may be allowed to take over firms in strategic industries.
- Leans: Free citizens need the freedom to own property, trade and choose work, or political freedom cannot last.
- Leans: One worker's pay need not cover the living needs of that worker's family.
- Leans: Individual rights matter at least as much as what citizens owe their community.
- Leans: Democracy is not the best form of government when voters choose badly.
- Leans: Marriage, inheritance and family law may differ between religious communities.
- Leans: Force is for self-defence alone.
- Leans: A national minority should run its own schools, language and cultural institutions inside the state it lives in.
- Leans: Belonging to the nation does not tie a person's life to a sacred community that goes on after their death.
- Leans: The farmers who work large estates should take ownership from the landowners, with the transfer compulsory if owners refuse.
- Leans: Military service should always be voluntary.
- Leans: Laws, institutions and customs today do not systematically favor men over women.
- Leans: Working together internationally should count at least as much as my country's own priorities.
- Leans: Politics should give compromises among competing groups at least as much weight as a single common good identified by reasoning.
- Leans: Religious values and institutions should not have a major part in shaping laws, schools and public life.
- Leans: State schools should not teach religion.
- Leans: Wage work cuts people off from the meaning and creativity of what they make.
- Leans: Those who hold public office should be paid no more than an average worker.
- Leans: Money creation should not be reserved exclusively to public institutions.
- Leans: Having wealth does not by itself create a duty to help those who are worse off.
- Leans: Women's equality can be fully achieved without transforming the economic system.
- Leans: Government should not be bound by a written bill of rights protected against easy amendment by ordinary majorities.
- Leans: Political power should be split among separate branches and levels that can each limit the others.
- Leans: Prisons should mainly help offenders rejoin society.
- Leans: Tariffs should not be used to protect domestic industry from foreign competition.
- Leans: Production should be organised to provide what people need, instead of being organised around what yields a profit.
- Leans: A woman who has sex outside marriage is doing something wrong.
- Leans: A person's body belongs entirely to that person.
- Leans: Government should serve people's good while respecting each person as more than an instrument of the state or community.
- Leans: Whoever uses land or resources owes the rest of society a share of their value.
- Leans: A law imposes no moral duty to obey it if the law is unjust.
- Leans: Without workers' own political power, state ownership is not socialism.
- Leans: A head of state may take a side in party politics.
- Leans: The national legislature should not be able to take back powers given to regions on its own.
- Leans: Tackling oppression does not require a combined approach to its overlapping forms, such as racism, sexism and class oppression.
- Leans: A constitution does not have to be drafted by an assembly elected for that purpose.
- Leans: Society may be changed in large, rapid steps.
- Leans: People without property should also have the right to vote.
- Leans: Taking part in politics is at least as good a way to live as living privately away from public affairs.
- Leans: Another body may have the final say over what the legislature passes.
- Leans: Most of government should be funded by taxes other than a tax on the value of land.
- Leans: You can't reach a free, fair society by unfree or unfair means.
- Leans: Killing another person can be right in self-defence or in defence of others.
- Leans: How someone turns out is shaped more by upbringing, society and experience than by the traits they are born with.
- Leans: Voting should not be limited to members of one ethnic group.
- Leans: Belonging to a religious minority is no ground for shoppers to stay away from a shop.
- Leans: Owners' rights to their property need not be protected against being overridden for public goals.
- Leans: The head of state should not be elected directly by the voters.
- Leans: Social duty should not take the place of material rewards as the main reason people work.
- Leans: An electorate should choose the head of state, either directly or through elected representatives.
- Leans: Government should rely at least as much on legal enforcement as on its rulers' moral example.
- Leans: A country need not treat an excess of exports over imports as something to aim for.
- Leans: Government should have other tasks besides protecting people from physical violence.
- Leans: Religious institutions should be independent of government direction in their internal affairs.
- Leans: The best constitution does not combine rule by the few with rule by the many.
- Leans: People should have a direct role in making decisions where they work, live and study, rather than having those decisions made entirely for them.
- Leans: The state should not be managed the way a well-run business is.
- Leans: Politics is not best understood as a contest between spiritual good and evil.
- Leans: Peoples who share an ethnic heritage, such as the Slavic peoples, should not come together in one state.
- Leans: A healthy society depends on the traditional family, such as a married mother and father raising their children.
- Leans: Political independence means little unless the economic and property system is also transformed.
- Leans: Marriage should retain legal recognition.
- Leans: Meeting poor people's needs should be the first consideration in public policy.
- Leans: In the long run people should still produce and share using money.
- Leans: Public institutions should have the power to constrain a national majority's decisions in a liberal democracy.
- Leans: Industrial society has done at least as much good as harm to humanity.
- Leans: Other things drive humanity forward at least as much as rivalry and conflict between peoples.
- Leans: Other forces move history at least as much as conflict between classes does.
- Leans: Most people in political office look after themselves first and the public second.
- Leans: Private ownership is legitimate only insofar as it benefits society.
- Leans: Racial groups should not each organise to defend distinct political interests of their own.
- Leans: At least some revolutions have been justified.
- Leans: War does not strengthen a nation's character.
- Leans: Looking after your own interests is not a moral good in itself.
- Leans: Lending money at interest should be legal.
- Leans: A government needs more than fair elections to be democratic.
- Leans: Poor countries should retain economic ties with rich countries.
- Leans: The law should treat everyone as an equal, whatever their birth, sex, race or status.